Wall of paint samples


At Cottage Supply Company, color is at our core. It is where we started. A paint store helping people every day find the perfect color...the perfect hue...the perfect sheen.

We love being involved in the process and a part of the moment when you find the perfect one that pulls everything together, the one that sets your room or your home apart.

Our people make the difference and go the extra mile when making or matching your color. Whether it’s adding a bump of this or a quarter-formula of that, we will spend the time to make sure you get the color you are looking for.

Our combined experience in our stores is well over 100 years. We understand that equally important to finding the right color is getting the right advice when you are tackling a project at your home. We have seen a lot over the years and we will utilize our experience to ensure that your project goes as smoothly as possible.

Stop by Cottage Supply Company and let us help you find the perfect color.

Below you can learn more about the premium paint lines we carry in our stores, and find links to their websites.

Cottage Color Boutique

Cottage Color Boutique is our own little baby. We have created an exclusive color palette of perfect colors for your home. Our paint is available in a low sheen eggshell finish and is a “paint and primer in one”. Cottage Color Boutique is also environmentally safe, meeting the most stringent standards in the paint industry. All of our colors are displayed using the actual paint so there is no guessing what the color or sheen will look like. Come by and pick up a color sample, which are also made with the actual paint.

Click here to visit our Tumblr blog.

Benjamin Moore

Cottage Supply Company is a Signature Store for Benjamin Moore, offering a full line of products and color material, along with experience to help you with your project. For well over 100 years Benjamin Moore has been making premium paint and creating the finest color palette on the planet. At their site you will find the latest in color trends and some great color tools to assist you in selecting the perfect color.

Click here to visit the Benjamin Moore website.


We carry Muralo’s super premium Ultra line. These products are water based and primarily for trim and cabinetry. They are known for their silky smooth finish and their ability to stick over oil (which is typically a no-no). They are available in satin, semi-gloss and high-gloss finishes, and can be made in any color.

Click here to visit the Muralo website.

ProLuxe (formerly Sikkens)

ProLuxe has been recognized as being a provider of super premium exterior stains. We stock the full SRD oil based semi transparent line and the window and door line in our stores. As a dealer we have access to their full line of exterior stain products. Our in-store display offers you a sneak peak at all of the options available for your project.

Click here to visit the ProLuxe website.

Zinsser Primers

If you are looking for the perfect primer, Zinsser has it and we carry it. If you have a water stain, smoke stain, tannin bleed or adhesion issues, Zinsser has the solution and our staff can help you in selecting the right one.

Click here to visit the Zinsser website.

Old Masters Stains

Old Masters Stains is quite simply the best stain line we have found over the years. We stock the Old Masters wiping stains in each of our stores. We have access to gel stains and penetrating stains as well. Old Masters has just added four new colors so stop by and take a peek at the color palette!

Click here to visit the Old Masters Stains website.